7 Different Approaches to Reading Instruction
Overview
Below, I provide an overview of seven commonly used approaches to reading instruction.
Each approach reflects different instructional priorities related to decoding, comprehension, vocabulary, and student engagement. By understanding these approaches, educators and families can make informed decisions about literacy instruction.
Decades of reading research show that systematic phonics instruction paired with decodable texts is the most effective way to teach students to read accurately and independently.
For additional background on reading research and instructional practices, listeners may find the podcast Sold a Story informative.
The Phonics Approach
The phonics approach focuses on explicitly teaching the relationship between letters and sounds so students can decode unfamiliar words.
Educators can explore my decodable text links organized by sound and spelling, as well as free decodable passages that support this approach.
| Category | Description |
|---|---|
| Reading Task Emphasized | Decoding—translating letter symbols into speech sounds |
| Motivational Approach | Increased skill and confidence in decoding printed words |
| Decoding Approach | Synthetic—begins with individual speech sounds and builds into words |
| Story Content | Stories are based on the sounds and spelling patterns being taught |
| Vocabulary Selection | Words selected for phonics regularity and applicable phonics rules |
| Vocabulary Difficulty | Regular short-vowel words are most accessible; irregular words are more difficult |
| Mode of Response | Emphasis on oral reading; some programs include moderate writing |
| Structure and Completeness | Varies by program, from highly structured to teacher-developed |
Internal resources related to phonics instruction and decodable reading practice can be found throughout this site.
The Whole Language Approach
In contrast to phonics, the whole language approach emphasizes meaning, authentic literature, and real-world language use. Teachers focus on helping students read for understanding rather than teaching explicit decoding skills.
| Category | Description |
|---|---|
| Reading Task Emphasized | Comprehension—constructing meaning from text |
| Motivational Approach | Enjoyment of authentic literature and meaningful reading experiences |
| Decoding Approach | Analytic—limited direct phonics instruction; emphasis on context, meaning, and visual cues |
| Story Content | Authentic children’s literature, trade books, and student-selected texts |
| Vocabulary Selection | Vocabulary is drawn from real literature and student interests rather than controlled word lists |
| Vocabulary Difficulty | Words are considered accessible if meaning can be inferred through context and background knowledge |
| Mode of Response | Silent reading, shared reading, discussion, journaling, and written responses |
| Structure and Completeness | Loosely structured; instruction is teacher-developed and literature-based rather than program-driven |
The Guided Reading Approach
Guided reading emphasizes comprehension and meaning-making while students read leveled texts. Instruction often incorporates multiple strategies to support understanding.
Furthermore, recent research raises concerns about instructional models that rely heavily on cueing rather than explicit decoding instruction; these concerns are discussed in the podcast Sold a Story.
| Category | Description |
|---|---|
| Reading Task Emphasized | Comprehension—understanding the meaning of printed text |
| Motivational Approach | Engagement with texts at a wide range of levels |
| Decoding Approach | Analytic strategies and limited synthetic phonics; use of cueing systems |
| Story Content | Increasingly complex texts labeled from levels A–Z |
| Vocabulary Selection | Primarily tier 2 vocabulary appearing across texts |
| Vocabulary Difficulty | Familiar spoken words are most accessible; unfamiliar words are learned through context |
| Mode of Response | Whisper or silent reading; comprehension assessed through discussion |
| Structure and Completeness | Teacher-developed programs with no single formal guide |
Educators interested in guided reading may explore The CAFE Book by Gail Boushey and Joan Moser, How to Teach Guided Reading, as well as materials by Fountas and Pinnell.
The Sight Word Approach
Another strategy, the sight word approach emphasizes memorization of frequently occurring words as whole units. Traditional basal reading programs used this approach.
You can discover examples of this approach on my free sight word stories page.
| Category | Description |
|---|---|
| Reading Task Emphasized | Comprehension—recognizing and understanding printed words |
| Motivational Approach | Enjoyment of familiar story content |
| Decoding Approach | Analytic—use of context and visual recognition |
| Story Content | Stories featuring recurring characters and everyday experiences |
| Vocabulary Selection | Words selected based on frequency of use by children |
| Vocabulary Difficulty | Familiar spoken words are easiest; unfamiliar words are more difficult |
| Mode of Response | Emphasis on silent reading; minimal writing |
| Structure and Completeness | Typically offered as a comprehensive program with teacher guides |
The Linguistic Approach
In addition, the linguistic approach relies on predictable spelling patterns to support word recognition and decoding.
| Category | Description |
|---|---|
| Reading Task Emphasized | Decoding—connecting printed words to spoken language |
| Motivational Approach | Increased accuracy in reading patterned words |
| Decoding Approach | Analytic—students analyze spelling patterns within whole words |
| Story Content | Stories organized around shared spelling patterns |
| Vocabulary Selection | Words selected based on spelling pattern consistency |
| Vocabulary Difficulty | Common patterns (CVC, CVCe) are most accessible |
| Mode of Response | Emphasis on oral reading; limited writing |
| Structure and Completeness | Highly structured and marketed as a complete program |
The Language Experience Approach
Teachers use the language experience approach to build on students’ oral language and shared classroom experiences. This approach encourages engagement and is commonly applied in preschool through first grade.
| Category | Description |
|---|---|
| Reading Task Emphasized | Comprehension—connecting meaning to print |
| Motivational Approach | Enjoyment of creating and reading personal stories |
| Decoding Approach | Analytic—moves from whole words to smaller units |
| Story Content | Student-generated stories based on shared experiences |
| Vocabulary Selection | Vocabulary drawn from students’ spoken language |
| Vocabulary Difficulty | Familiar spoken words are most accessible |
| Mode of Response | Silent reading followed by oral reading and writing |
| Structure and Completeness | Considered a complete approach with minimal formal structure |
The Multisensory Approach
Finally, multisensory instruction—including Orton-Gillingham and Wilson-based programs—integrates visual, auditory, and tactile pathways simultaneously.
| Category | Description |
|---|---|
| Reading Task Emphasized | Decoding—linking letter symbols to speech sounds |
| Motivational Approach | Increased decoding skill through active engagement |
| Decoding Approach | Synthetic—explicit instruction with strong motor involvement |
| Story Content | Texts aligned with taught sounds and motor patterns |
| Vocabulary Selection | Words selected based on phonics rules and regularity |
| Vocabulary Difficulty | Regular short-vowel words are easiest; irregular words are more difficult |
| Mode of Response | Writing, motor activities, and oral reading |
| Structure and Completeness | Highly structured programs often paired with other instruction |
Return to HOME
You can download an editable version of the “Different Approaches to Reading Instruction” page from Instant Downloads.
This page was last updated on January 6, 2026.